If I had a Chrysalis and a Monarch of equal weight (say 10 oz) would
the Monarch be noticeably better and in what way?
From : Don Stackhouse
When we first developed the Chrysalis we noticed that it's performance in
light air was surprisingly competitive with the Monarch 'C'. Good
advertising for the Chrysalis but bad for Monarch 'C' sales! At the same
time a lot of folks were asking for a light air contest ship with better
launch height. In the Monarch 'D' we used the latest aerodynamics
technology we developed while designing the Chrysalis and Wizard to come up
with the ultimate 2-channel light air model, both in performance and handling.
The Monarch 'D-lite' would be somewhat overweight at 10 oz., 8.9 to 9.5 is
more typical for the ones we build for ourselves. I believe that an
excellent builder using the newest techniques and ultra-micro radios could
probably get one under 8.5 oz.. The Chrysalis is overweight at 10 oz., 8.5
to 9.5 is more typical for a very good one, but because of the variables of
builder technique and wood properties, the Chrysalis does seem to have a
wider variation in weight than the highly pre-fabricated Monarch. With some
heroic measures and serious modifications (check the notes on our website
about Eric Farmer's 7 oz. Chrysalis) it is possible to get an un-painted
Chysalis down to ridiculously low weights, although I suspect that a flier
with a really strong arm would probably see some flutter on Eric's model
because of the lightweight covering.
Getting back to your question, the Monarch 'D-lite' has significantly
better handling (especially in turns), much better launch height (almost as
good as the Wizard), better penetration and L/D, and better sink rate and
thermalling ability. The Chrysalis is an excellent model as low-cost
built-up ships go, but it is no match for a Monarch 'D' or 'D-lite'.
Next how does the monarch compare to the Chrysalis in wind (say 10-12 MPH)?
Better. Significantly better. Both models also respond well to ballast,
unlike the earlier Monarchs. However, at 10-12 mph you're getting close to
Wizard territory. The Monarch 'D' will do well at 12 kts (14 mph) and more,
but the Wizard is "just coming into its element" at those wind speeds. In
anything more than about 12 kts I would probably choose the Wizard.
Don Stackhouse @ DJ Aerotech
|