Does a pusher configuration perfom better than ducted fan for the same
airframe, consider for example the P-80, how would it perform better?
From : Don Stackhouse
That depends on the specific application, but for most model applications
I'd say the answer is a guarded "yes". The key here is diameter. For low
speed thrust, more diameter is better. Although at static situations a duct
can help, a sufficiently bigger diameter will usually be more efficient
than a duct, especially as the speed picks up a bit. Pushers tend to be
limited on diameter in many situations than a comparable tractor prop, but
they are still usually quite a bit bigger than a typical ducted fan. This
gives them an advantage over the fan in those situations.
If the pusher prop and fan are limited to equal diameters, the picture
changes. The fan's duct limits the tip losses at static and very low speed
flight conditions, and provides some benefits in the way the fan can use
its diameter (it allows for non-zero thrust at the tip of the blade),
giving it better thrust at low speeds. As speed increases, the tip losses
diminish, while the drag of the duct itself increases, until at some
"crossover velocity" the drag of the duct becomes larger than the benefits
it provides in tip losses. All other things being equal, above the
crossover velocity the prop will be better, but below the crossover
velocity, the fan will have an advantage.
Don Stackhouse
DJ Aerotech
|