Is it typical very tight turns (~45degree bank) when thermalling?
Because I am a lonely flyer...
I have not seen another Rc gliders, so I decided to buy the Old Buzzard
goes to fly Video and it was a little surprise the way this guy was flying
the Gentle Lady. All I have heard is to fly with smooth turns... but this
guy was making so tighten turns with more than 45 degrees of wing bank. It
also seems to be flying so fast for a Gentle Lady...Is that the way a
Gentle lady flies?
Oscar, depending on the circumstances, that is how most, if not all, R/C
sailplanes fly if the lift conditions demand it. There is no conflict
between what you saw on the video and the "fly with smooth turns" advice.
Just because a turn uses a small radius and a steep bank angle does NOT
mean that it isn't smooth. In fact, often those extremenly tight radius
turns require the smoothest flying of all! "Smooth" means precise,
economical and deliberate motions, it does not mean timid.
In general, when someone advises you to "fly smoothly", what they mean is
to fly your model with only the minimum control inputs required by the
maneuver, without a lot of extraneous bobbling and sashaying around. If you
really know your model, then for a given roll rate into a bank, you know
instinctivly just how much rudder (or aileron) to apply for precisely the
right amount of time. You move the stick that far, for that amount of time,
and in still air the model rolls into the turn exactly the way you
expected. Once at the desired bank angle, you know instinctivly how much
rudder and elevator is needed, in whatever direction, to hold that bank
angle. You instinctivly move the stick to that position, and the model
holds the desired turn, smooth and round. You don't have to keep
experimenting with different stick positions, trying to find the "right
spot", while your model stalls and sqiggles and squirms across the sky in
lumpy shaped circles.
All of this is true regardless of whether you're making a 2-wingspan
diameter circle with a 40-60 degree bank to stay inside the tiny core of a
small diameter thermal at low altitude, or flying a wider, flatter, more
gentle circle as the thermal widens out at higher altitude. The shape and
size of the thermal might require fast roll rates to get into it, and steep
banks to stay in it, but even in those situations you MUST fly smoothly and
deliberately.
There are several reasons for doing all of this smoothly and precisely.
First of all, safety: if you're squggling around all over the place as you
try to establish your turn at low altitude, you increase the chances of
stalling inadvertently (perhaps without enough altitude to recover), or
running into something (trees, buildings, other people, etc.). Flying at
minimum sink speed in a 50 degree bank less than 2 meters off the ground in
a turbulent "boomer" thermal is no time to be flying erratically!
Secondly, the least drag is the natural result of making the least control
movements. Every time you make a bigger than necessary control input, you
are making more than the minimum amount of control surface drag. You're
also wasting more than the minimum necessary amount of power from the
battery, which could be a factor on long flights or on small models with
very small batteries (such as HLG'S).
Last but not least:
When you apply the expected amount of control to your model, and it doesn't
respond the way you expected, that means it's trying to tell you something.
It usually means theat the air around your glider is doing something, and
your glider is trying to tell you about it. When you're flying in a
straight line, holding the controls for a straight flight path, and the
left wing suddenly starts to rise all by itself, that could mean there's an
updraft to the left, lifting the left wingtip. It could also mean there's a
patch of sink on the right. In either case, the model is trying to tell
you, "Hey, pal, I think it would be best for both of us if you turn me to
the left!" If the nose rises momentarily, then immediately the tail rises
and the model starts to accelerate, your model is telling you "Look! I just
flew straight into an updraft!" If you are holding the controls in the
position for a smooth, round, constant sink rate, constant radius thermal
turn, but your model is rising more on one side of the circle than the
other, it's trying to tell you that the core of the thermal is "over that
way!"
You talk to your model with your control stick movements. It talks to you
with subtle changes in attitude and flight path. If you are not "smooth" on
the controls (i.e.: you make more frequent and larger stick motions than
absolutely necessary), then you are, in effect, yelling and jabbering at
it, but NOT doing very much listening. Your squiggly, wobbly flight path
commands will obscure the subtle little whispers that your model is trying
to say to you. Only when you learn to fly smoothly, with a minimum of
control movements, will you begin to "hear" what your model is trying to
say. The secret of better flying is to do less "talking" and more
"listening". That's really what we mean by "flying smoothly".
Take another look at the video. Yes, he makes some steep banks. In some
cases he might make some exaggerated movements just to make it easier for
you to see the behavior of the model he is trying to explain, but for the
most part he and the model are simply responding appropriately to the
motions of the air around them. That's really what soaring is all about!
Don Stackhouse @ DJ Aerotech
|