I'm getting ready to start building my Spectre 120. I've got a couple of questions / concerns to ask you about.
1. I'm led to believe that the aileron hinge cut made to form the aileron is made with a continous width?
IE. As you get closer to the upper skin, the 3/32nd gap of material removed doesn't narrow. Am I correct?
From : Don Stackhouse
That's correct. Think of the skin hinge on the upper surface as a very
short, but very wide leaf spring. The stiffness of a leaf spring depends
(among other things) on its thickness (in this case the thickness of the
upper surface skin) and on the spring's length (in this case the width of
the hinge slot). Both of those are constants along the span of the hinge.
The thickness of the foam removed is not a factor in the stiffness of the
hinge, only the width of the slot.
If you taper the slot, the stiffness of the hinge will increase in the
narrowed areas, which will also increase the stresses in the upper skin
when the aileron is deflected. This could result in overstressing the upper
skin, which could (in extreme cases) lead to cracking of the skin.
My other item is a concern. The plans show the aileron extends to within 4 inches from the tip.
This leaves a very narrow section of wing between the leading edge of the aileron and the leading
edge of the wing. Is the tip strong enough???
Excellent question, and yes, it is strong enough. The carbon spars are what
give the tip its strength, and those run all the way to the tip,
undisturbed, ahead of the hinge slot. In addition, on the Spectre 120 we do
not make a chordwise cut at the outer end of the aileron, so the aileron is
still tied to the tip. Although this doesn't have much effect on the
up-and-down bending strength of the tip (carbon is so much stiffer than the
fiberglass skin that the added bending strength of the fiberglass skin of
the aileron in that direction doesn't really add that much to the total),
the lack of a chordwise cut does help reduce stress concentrations in that
area, and it also does add significantly to the fore-and-aft bending
strength of the tip.
Note, the tip is plenty strong enough even with a chordwise cut at the tip
of the aileron, for folks who insist on doing it the conventional way.
However, leaving the aileron tied at the tip improves the strength and
flutter resistance of both the wingtip and the aileron, it reduces edges
that can catch on stuff during landing, it reduces aerodynamic drag, and it
alters the twist distribution when the ailerons are drooped in concert with
the flaps for thermalling. Roll response is excellent with the tied tips at
all flap deflections, provided you set up the ailerons per the instructions.
Aerodynamically, this change in washout distribution due to the tied
aileron tips accomplishes much the same thing as the latest trend toward
six-servo wings (i.e.: with thermalling flaps deployed, it keeps the lift
distribution more smooth and elliptical than a four-servo wing with
non-tied aileron tips or with trilerons can do). However, according to our
analyses, the lift distribution from our four-servo Spectre 120 wing with
tied aileron tips is even smoother and more elliptical than a six-servo
wing with conventional ailerons, and without all the extra weight,
complexity and cost of the extra servos.
Don Stackhouse
DJ Aerotech
|